Skip to content

Brought to you by

Dentons logo

Limitations Law Blog

Updates on key developments on laws involving limitation periods in Ontario.

open menu close menu

Limitations Law Blog

  • Home
  • About us

Limitations Defences Must be Pleaded and Argued

By Ara Basmadjian
April 1, 2021
  • General
Share on Facebook Share on Twitter Share via email Share on LinkedIn

In Hayward v. Hayward, 2021 ONCA 175 (“Hayward”), the Court of Appeal for Ontario provided a reminder of the established principle that limitations defences must be pleaded and argued.

Hayward is an estate matter. It involves the late Jeanne Hayward (“Jeanne”), her former husband, Alexander Hayward (“Alex”), and their five children, including Leslie Hayward (“Leslie”). Alex appealed from the trial judge’s decision regarding his claims to repayment of a loan he made to Jeanne, which she used to buy a car, and to ownership of a tractor. Alex also sought leave to appeal the costs award.

The trial judge found, among other things, that Alex had made a down payment of $1,000 and owned the tractor. However, the trial judge went on to determine that Leslie had paid the remaining $12,560, which was most of the purchase price. There was no evidence that Alex ever repaid Leslie. Accordingly, the trial judge held that Alex owed Leslie the amount of $12,560.

On appeal, Alex argued that repayment of the loan was time-barred. The Court of Appeal dismissed this ground of appeal because it was not raised before the trial judge:

The appellant argues that the trial judge erred in failing to find that repayment of the loan was time-barred under the Limitations Act, 2002, S.O. 2002, c. 24. This proceeding was started as an application and did not have full pleadings, but it was open to counsel to raise the application of the Limitations Act as a defence to Leslie’s claim. The trial judge cannot be criticized for failing to respond to a defence that was not raised by counsel. This ground of appeal is dismissed.

Counsel should be aware that the expiry of a limitation period is an affirmative defence. As Hayward demonstrates, an appellate court will not consider a limitations defence that is not pleaded or raised at first instance.

Share on Facebook Share on Twitter Share via email Share on LinkedIn
Subscribe and stay updated
Receive our latest blog posts by email.
Stay in Touch
Ara Basmadjian

About Ara Basmadjian

Ara Basmadjian is a Partner in the Litigation and Dispute Resolution group at Dentons Canada LLP. His practice involves a variety of complex corporate, commercial and civil litigation matters. Ara has particular experience in cases involving commercial contracts, negligence, product liability, class actions, competition law, cannabis in Canada, and extraordinary remedies, such as injunctions.

All posts Full bio

RELATED POSTS

  • General

Civil Procedure and Practice in Ontario, 2021

By Ara Basmadjian
  • General
  • Limitation Periods contained in "Other Acts"

A Statute-Barred Claim is Not a Provable Claim in Bankruptcy

By Ara Basmadjian

About Dentons

Dentons is designed to be different. As the world’s largest law firm with 20,000 professionals in over 200 locations in more than 80 countries, we can help you grow, protect, operate and finance your business. Our polycentric and purpose-driven approach, together with our commitment to inclusion, diversity, equity and ESG, ensures we challenge the status quo to stay focused on what matters most to you. www.dentons.com

Dentons boilerplate image

Twitter

Categories

  • Acknowledgment
  • Adding a Party
  • Amending Pleadings
  • Attempted Resolution
  • Contribution and Indemnity
  • COVID-19
  • Demand Obligations
  • Discoverability
  • Enforcement of Foreign Judgments
  • General
  • Limitation Periods contained in "Other Acts"
  • Limitation Periods in Federal Court
  • Misnomer
  • Motions to Strike
  • Notable cases in other provinces
  • Special Circumstances
  • Statutory Variation of Time Limits
  • Successors
  • Tolling/Varying Agreements
  • Transitional Provisions
  • Ultimate Limitation Periods

Subscribe and stay updated

Receive our latest blog posts by email.

Stay in Touch

Dentons logo

© 2023 Dentons

  • Legal notices
  • Privacy policy
  • Terms of use
  • Cookies on this site